Is civil commitment protection, punishment, prison–or purgatory?

Viewing 2 reply threads
  • Author
    • #22166 Reply
      Sandy Rozek
      Sandy Rozek

      By Maurice Chammah…. If someone finishes a prison sentence for a violent sexual crime, but might still be dangerous, should he be released? How do y
      [See the full post at: Is civil commitment protection, punishment, prison–or purgatory?]

    • #22168 Reply
      Tony From Long Island

      Judging by the two previous Supreme Court decisions on this topic, I am not optimistic. However, it has been quite a while since the visited the issue, so there might be hope.

      • #22188 Reply
        Jeremy from Indiana

        If you are talking about McKune v. Lile and Smith v. Doe, then I wouldn’t worry about those too much. Justice Kennedy is the same one who wrote the former opinion and in Packingham v. North Carolina, he showed us that he thinks quite a bit differently now. This will be a completely different battle in 2018 than it was in 2002. There is a lot more research and evidence on the subject now and the registry today is unrecognizable from the registry presented in those cases. I am cautiously optimistic that this will be the year the registry falls apart completely.

        • #22254 Reply

          Jeremy from Indiana, If it looks like a duck, walks like a duck them hey it must be a duck. I don’t see how they can keep these so called treatment prisons open, especially that they keep prisoners well passed release dates, it’s just ridiculous. The proof is on the table, they know damn well the the statistics from 10 20 or 30 years ago have drastically changed and the rcividisism lie that they keep putting into people’s heads can be seen plane as day now and they can no longer lie about it, the courts know what’s happening,
          I’m in PA and looks like a lot is happening arround the country for registered citizens thank God, but these other people of power are fighting it as well. DA Freed is asking the SCOTUS to review the PA Supreme courts decision in the cancelation of the AWA/SORNA in PA. I don’t understand how they can make PA Supreme Court change the ruling that has already been done.

    • #22331 Reply

      I am praying for all that are working to change this. It is a system that does. It work.

      • #23566 Reply
        Will Crump

        The court sided with fear and has declined to hear the case. I am not surprised because the S.C.O.T.U.S. would have went against their own previous rulings. I suppose freedom after serving time for the crime is NOT worthy of the Court’s attention or strictest scrutiny. This is really discouraging. Prejudice is so hard to overcome, especially when it’s on the part of the ones who hold all the aces.

        I wonder how much the “frightening and high” myth played into this. I also wonder how much back-room politics played a role in the Court’s decision to decline hearing the case.

Viewing 2 reply threads
Reply To: Is civil commitment protection, punishment, prison–or purgatory?
We welcome a lively discussion with all view points provided that they stay on topic - keeping in mind...

  • *You must be 18 or older to comment.
  • *You must check the "I am not a robot" box and follow the recaptcha instructions.
  • *Your submission must be approved by a NARSOL moderator.
  • *Moderating decisions may be subjective.
  • *Comments arguing about political or religious preferences will be deleted.
  • *Excessively long replies will be rejected, without explanation.
  • *Be polite and courteous. This is a public forum.
  • *Do not post in ALL CAPS.
  • *Stay on topic.
  • *Do not post contact information for yourself or another person.
  • *Please enter a name that does not contain links to other websites.

Your information:

<a href="" title="" rel="" target=""> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <pre class=""> <em> <strong> <del datetime="" cite=""> <ins datetime="" cite=""> <ul> <ol start=""> <li> <img src="" border="" alt="" height="" width="">