Study validates alternatives to prison more effective for some offenses

By Milton J. Valencia . . . The progressive movement to divert nonviolent offenders to treatment rather than charging them with a crime has faced a drumbeat of criticism over the years focused on the same central theme: Criminals who don’t pay for their offenses are more likely to commit a crime again.

Now, a first-of-its-kind independent research study conducted in Suffolk County has undercut this opposition. The study, which analyzed nearly two decades of data, found that not prosecuting low-level crimes was more successful in directing nonviolent offenders away from the criminal justice system.

“Keeping these individuals out of the criminal justice system seems to have an effect; it seems to stop the path of criminal activity from escalating, and that’s the takeaway from this study,” said Anna Harvey, a professor at New York University, who partnered with colleagues from Rutgers University and Texas A&M University to conduct the review, which was published Monday by the National Bureau of Economic Research.

The report is among the first to support, with data, the progressive criminal justice movement away from tough-on-crime tactics and toward policies that divert defendants accused of certain low-level crimes to social service programs, rather than the criminal justice system. The belief is that the diversion prevents a cycle of incarceration and repeat offenses.

Suffolk District Attorney Rachael Rollins won a surprise victory in 2018 touting these types of policies, overcoming more conservative opponents who vowed to be tougher on crime. Since taking office in 2019, Rollins has had to fend off criticism that her effort to effectively decriminalize 15 categories of nonviolent low-level crimes such as shoplifting and driving offenses is too easy on criminals; her opponents argue that letting criminals go without punishment encourages them to commit more crimes.

Read the full piece here at the Boston Globe.

Help us reach more people by Sharing or Liking this post.

Viewing 1 reply thread
  • Author
    • #82547 Reply

      Tim in WI

      There will be a time when public notification via database is the only punishment for a crime. A cheap alternative to be sure. We’re already engaged in indecent public exposure for the crime of indecent public exposure!

      Citizens in question: “What’d ya do to get pinched?”
      Offending Man: “This!! ” ~ Drops his pants.
      Citizens in question: “OMG!”
      Offensive Man: “You asked.”

    • #82636 Reply


      This 100% true, I have read the research docs also. Specifically about Pennsylvania because how bad the incarceration rate is as well as the quantity of people on supervision and the stagering high numbers of people returned to prison for a violation of supervision, not an actual crime…!!!

      This is the one reason why I am in complete favor of Defunding the current criminal justice system. Simply for the fact the current criminal justice system is not making society safer nor are they helping anyone to be a positive, productive citizen.

      Our current system makes society worse and destroys local communities as well as the individual who gets introduced to it.

Viewing 1 reply thread
Reply To: Reply #82547 in Study validates alternatives to prison more effective for some offenses
We welcome a lively discussion with all view points provided that they stay on topic - keeping in mind...

  • *You must be 18 or older to comment.
  • *You must check the "I am not a robot" box and follow the recaptcha instructions.
  • *Your submission must be approved by a NARSOL moderator.
  • *Moderating decisions may be subjective.
  • *Comments arguing about political or religious preferences will be deleted.
  • *Excessively long replies will be rejected, without explanation.
  • *Be polite and courteous. This is a public forum.
  • *Do not post in ALL CAPS.
  • *Stay on topic.
  • *Do not post contact information for yourself or another person.
  • *Please enter a name that does not contain links to other websites.

Your information:

<a href="" title="" rel="" target=""> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <pre class=""> <em> <strong> <del datetime="" cite=""> <ins datetime="" cite=""> <ul> <ol start=""> <li> <img src="" border="" alt="" height="" width="">